« Eric Segall on Originalism and Structural Reasoning
Michael Ramsey
| Main | Michael Lewis: Protecting Our Constitution Through an Anti-Originalist Interpretive Canon of Constitutional Interpretation
Michael Ramsey »

08/30/2019

Evan Bernick & Christopher Green: What is the Object of the Article VI Oath?
Michael Ramsey

Evan D. Bernick (judicial clerk) and Christopher R. Green (University of Mississippi - School of Law) have posted What is the Object of the Article VI Oath? (54 pages) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

How and why are officers today bound to the Constitution? Article VI gives us a crystal-clear answer: they are bound “by oath or affirmation, to support this Constitution.” But what is the content — the object — of that promise? American constitutional culture today describes its Constitution in ways that presuppose that the Article VI oath binds office-holders to an external, objective, common object: the same commitment for all oath-takers today, and the same commitment today as in the past. Justices on the Supreme Court took their constitutional oaths at different times, spread out over 27 years from 1991 to 2018, but they claim to fulfill those nine oaths by speaking collectively of “the Constitution.” Americans regularly describe their Constitution as the oldest still-operational written national Constitution in the world. These sorts of contingent practices could of course change. But until they do, we should understand oath-takers to be swearing to obey the same entity which has been operative since the eighteenth century. If we have a living Constitution today, it must have been living from the very start. Our current constitutional culture correctly rejects post-Founding “constitutional abiogenesis” — a transition from a non-living to a living Constitution between the Founding and today. Change in constitutional requirements may be justified only if rooted in the rules for constitutional change operative at the Founding.

Via Larry Solum at Legal Theory Blog, who say "Highly recommended.  Download it while it's hot!"