« Michael Greve: Originalism as Ideology
Michael Ramsey
| Main | What an “Inalienable Natural Right” Originally Meant (Updated)
Andrew Hyman »

04/27/2019

William Baude: Adjudication Outside Article III
Michael Ramsey

William Baude (University of Chicago - Law School) has posted Adjudication Outside Article III (133 Harvard Law Review (forthcoming)) (61 pages) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract: 

Article III requires federal courts that exercise federal jurisdiction to be given life tenure and undiminished compensation, limiting Congress’s ability to influence the judiciary. But from the beginning, we have accepted certain forms of adjudication outside Article III – state courts, most obviously, but also territorial courts, administrative adjudication of public rights, and military tribunals. The question is why.

This article attempts to provide an answer. It argues that it is a mistake to focus on the act of adjudication itself; adversary presentation about the application of law to fact is simply a procedure, and not a procedure uniquely limited to Article III courts. Instead, the constitutional question is one of government power. What kind of power has the tribunal been vested with and what it is trying to do with that power? 

With this framework in view, the structure and scope of non-Article-III adjudication becomes clearer. Some courts exercise the judicial power of some other government. This is why territorial courts and state courts are constitutional. Some bodies exercise executive power, subject to the constraints reflected by the Due Process Clause. This is why administrative adjudication of public rights and military trials are constitutional. Some exercise no governmental power, and can proceed only as an adjunct to another entity, or on the basis of consent. This is the only basis on which magistrate judges and bankruptcy judges can proceed, and may render some of their current behavior unconstitutional.

(Via Larry Solum at Legal Theory Blog, who says: "Highly recommended.  Download it while it's hot!")