« Martin Lederman: History's Lessons for Wartime Military Tribunals
Michael Ramsey
| Main | Eric Segall on Justice Scalia's Legacy
Michael Ramsey »

09/23/2016

John McGinnis: The Continuity of the Fourteenth Amendment with the Founding
Michael Ramsey

At Liberty Law Blog, John McGinnis: The Continuity of the Fourteenth Amendment with the Founding.  From the introduction:

At a splendid conference at the University of the South last weekend, the most important underlying theme turned out to be the question of the continuity of the 14th Amendment with the rest of the constitution. Some scholars—indeed most– argued that the Reconstruction Amendments represented a second founding and a radical break with the past.

In contrast, I believe that there is substantial continuity between these two essential parts of our charter of liberty.  The 14th Amendment advanced and opened to all the commercial republic that was at the heart of the original Constitution. By their secession and actions leading up to succession, the South showed that it recognized that commercial dynamism and freedoms of the original founding would doom slavery. The Civil War just accelerated the realization of guarantees that flowed from principles implicit in the original Constitution. ...