« Greg Weiner on Federalism and the Halbig Litigation
Michael Ramsey
| Main | Andrew Hyman on Dormant Powers
Michael Ramsey
»

10/26/2014

Suzanna Sherry: The Classical Constitution and the Historical Constitution
Michael Ramsey

Suzanna Sherry (Vanderbilt University - Law School) has posted The Classical Constitution and the Historical Constitution: Separated at Birth (8 NYU Journal of Law & Liberty 983 (2014)) on SSRN. Here is the abstract: 

As part of symposium on Richard Epstein’s new book, The Classical Liberal Constitution, this article points out that his purportedly historical approach is actually present-oriented, which undermines two particular parts of his analysis. First, his discussion of judicial review mischaracterizes both judicial review itself and its history. Second, his discussion of abortion restrictions as valid exercises of the police power ignores the historical evidence. That evidence demonstrates that abortion restrictions were enacted for exactly the sort of wealth-transferring, monopoly-creating reasons that he finds unconstitutional in other contexts.