« Ephraim Unell: The First Word Revisited
Michael Ramsey
| Main | Seth Barrett Tillman's Answers on "Officers" and "Offices"
Michael Ramsey


Barnett, Kerr and Somin on Federalism and Constitutional Gestalt
Michael Ramsey

At Volokh Conspiracy, an exchange on the Supreme Court's commitment (or lack thereof) to federalism.

Randy Barnett: Who Won the Obamamcare Case (and Why Did So Many Law Porofessors Miss the Boat?)

Ilya Somin: Comstock, Bond, and Predictions About the Individual Mandate Case

Orin  Kerr: Understanding the New Federalism and the Rehnquist Court: A Response to Randy

Randy Barnett: Ain't Prognosticatin'

The core question remains, I think , whether the Court is willing to take meaningful -- as opposed to symbolic -- steps toward a federalism revival.  (Of course, the fact that the Court has been willing to take several symbolic steps is, as Professor Barnett says, itself a considerable shift in what he -- and Larry Solum -- call the "constitutional gestalt".  When I was in law school, even the idea of symbolic steps was laughable.)